

Currently released so far... 12900 / 251,287
Browse latest releases
2010/12/01
2010/12/02
2010/12/03
2010/12/04
2010/12/05
2010/12/06
2010/12/07
2010/12/08
2010/12/09
2010/12/10
2010/12/11
2010/12/12
2010/12/13
2010/12/14
2010/12/15
2010/12/16
2010/12/17
2010/12/18
2010/12/19
2010/12/20
2010/12/21
2010/12/22
2010/12/23
2010/12/24
2010/12/25
2010/12/26
2010/12/27
2010/12/28
2010/12/29
2010/12/30
2011/01/01
2011/01/02
2011/01/04
2011/01/05
2011/01/07
2011/01/09
2011/01/10
2011/01/11
2011/01/12
2011/01/13
2011/01/14
2011/01/15
2011/01/16
2011/01/17
2011/01/18
2011/01/19
2011/01/20
2011/01/21
2011/01/22
2011/01/23
2011/01/24
2011/01/25
2011/01/26
2011/01/27
2011/01/28
2011/01/29
2011/01/30
2011/01/31
2011/02/01
2011/02/02
2011/02/03
2011/02/04
2011/02/05
2011/02/06
2011/02/07
2011/02/08
2011/02/09
2011/02/10
2011/02/11
2011/02/12
2011/02/13
2011/02/14
2011/02/15
2011/02/16
2011/02/17
2011/02/18
2011/02/19
2011/02/20
2011/02/21
2011/02/22
2011/02/23
2011/02/24
2011/02/25
2011/02/26
2011/02/27
2011/02/28
2011/03/01
2011/03/02
2011/03/03
2011/03/04
2011/03/05
2011/03/06
2011/03/07
2011/03/08
2011/03/09
2011/03/10
2011/03/11
2011/03/13
2011/03/14
2011/03/15
2011/03/16
2011/03/17
2011/03/18
2011/03/19
2011/03/20
2011/03/21
2011/03/22
2011/03/23
2011/03/24
2011/03/25
2011/03/26
2011/03/27
2011/03/28
2011/03/29
2011/03/30
2011/03/31
2011/04/01
2011/04/02
2011/04/03
2011/04/04
2011/04/05
2011/04/06
2011/04/07
2011/04/08
2011/04/09
2011/04/10
2011/04/11
2011/04/12
2011/04/13
2011/04/14
2011/04/15
2011/04/16
2011/04/17
2011/04/18
2011/04/19
2011/04/20
2011/04/21
2011/04/22
2011/04/23
2011/04/24
2011/04/25
2011/04/26
2011/04/27
2011/04/28
2011/04/29
2011/04/30
2011/05/01
2011/05/02
2011/05/03
2011/05/04
2011/05/05
2011/05/06
2011/05/07
2011/05/08
2011/05/09
2011/05/10
2011/05/11
2011/05/12
2011/05/13
2011/05/14
2011/05/15
2011/05/16
2011/05/17
2011/05/18
2011/05/19
2011/05/20
2011/05/21
2011/05/22
2011/05/23
2011/05/24
Browse by creation date
Browse by origin
Embassy Athens
Embassy Asuncion
Embassy Astana
Embassy Asmara
Embassy Ashgabat
Embassy Apia
Embassy Ankara
Embassy Amman
Embassy Algiers
Embassy Addis Ababa
Embassy Accra
Embassy Abuja
Embassy Abu Dhabi
Embassy Abidjan
Consulate Auckland
Consulate Amsterdam
Consulate Adana
American Institute Taiwan, Taipei
Embassy Bujumbura
Embassy Buenos Aires
Embassy Budapest
Embassy Bucharest
Embassy Brussels
Embassy Bridgetown
Embassy Bratislava
Embassy Brasilia
Embassy Bogota
Embassy Bishkek
Embassy Bern
Embassy Berlin
Embassy Belmopan
Embassy Belgrade
Embassy Beirut
Embassy Beijing
Embassy Banjul
Embassy Bangkok
Embassy Bandar Seri Begawan
Embassy Bamako
Embassy Baku
Embassy Baghdad
Consulate Barcelona
Embassy Copenhagen
Embassy Conakry
Embassy Colombo
Embassy Chisinau
Embassy Caracas
Embassy Canberra
Embassy Cairo
Consulate Curacao
Consulate Ciudad Juarez
Consulate Chennai
Consulate Casablanca
Consulate Cape Town
Consulate Calgary
Embassy Dushanbe
Embassy Dublin
Embassy Doha
Embassy Djibouti
Embassy Dili
Embassy Dhaka
Embassy Dar Es Salaam
Embassy Damascus
Embassy Dakar
Consulate Dubai
Embassy Helsinki
Embassy Harare
Embassy Hanoi
Consulate Ho Chi Minh City
Consulate Hermosillo
Consulate Hamilton
Consulate Hamburg
Consulate Halifax
Embassy Kyiv
Embassy Kuwait
Embassy Kuala Lumpur
Embassy Kinshasa
Embassy Kingston
Embassy Kigali
Embassy Khartoum
Embassy Kathmandu
Embassy Kampala
Embassy Kabul
Consulate Kolkata
Consulate Karachi
Embassy Luxembourg
Embassy Luanda
Embassy London
Embassy Ljubljana
Embassy Lisbon
Embassy Lima
Embassy Lilongwe
Embassy La Paz
Consulate Lahore
Consulate Lagos
Mission USOSCE
Mission USNATO
Mission UNESCO
Embassy Muscat
Embassy Moscow
Embassy Montevideo
Embassy Monrovia
Embassy Minsk
Embassy Mexico
Embassy Mbabane
Embassy Maputo
Embassy Manila
Embassy Manama
Embassy Managua
Embassy Malabo
Embassy Madrid
Consulate Munich
Consulate Mumbai
Consulate Montreal
Consulate Monterrey
Consulate Milan
Consulate Melbourne
Embassy Nicosia
Embassy Niamey
Embassy New Delhi
Embassy Ndjamena
Embassy Nassau
Embassy Nairobi
Consulate Naples
Consulate Naha
Embassy Pristina
Embassy Pretoria
Embassy Prague
Embassy Port Of Spain
Embassy Port Louis
Embassy Port Au Prince
Embassy Phnom Penh
Embassy Paris
Embassy Paramaribo
Embassy Panama
Consulate Peshawar
REO Basrah
Embassy Rome
Embassy Riyadh
Embassy Riga
Embassy Reykjavik
Embassy Rangoon
Embassy Rabat
Consulate Rio De Janeiro
Consulate Recife
Secretary of State
Embassy Suva
Embassy Stockholm
Embassy Sofia
Embassy Skopje
Embassy Singapore
Embassy Seoul
Embassy Sarajevo
Embassy Santo Domingo
Embassy Santiago
Embassy Sanaa
Embassy San Salvador
Embassy San Jose
Consulate Strasbourg
Consulate St Petersburg
Consulate Shenyang
Consulate Shanghai
Consulate Sapporo
Consulate Sao Paulo
Embassy Tunis
Embassy Tripoli
Embassy Tokyo
Embassy The Hague
Embassy Tel Aviv
Embassy Tehran
Embassy Tegucigalpa
Embassy Tbilisi
Embassy Tashkent
Embassy Tallinn
Consulate Toronto
Consulate Tijuana
USUN New York
USEU Brussels
US Office Almaty
US Mission Geneva
US Interests Section Havana
US Delegation, Secretary
UNVIE
Embassy Ulaanbaatar
Embassy Vilnius
Embassy Vienna
Embassy Vatican
Embassy Valletta
Consulate Vladivostok
Consulate Vancouver
Browse by tag
AE
ASEC
AS
AR
AMGT
AFIN
AORC
AU
AG
AF
APER
ABLD
ADCO
ABUD
AM
AID
AJ
AEMR
AMED
AL
ASUP
AN
AIT
ACOA
ANET
ASIG
AA
AGMT
AINF
AFFAIRS
ADANA
AY
AADP
ARF
ACS
AGR
AMCHAMS
AECL
AUC
APEC
APECO
AFGHANISTAN
ACAO
ASEAN
ADM
AGAO
AND
ADPM
ATRN
ALOW
AROC
APCS
AORG
AO
AODE
ACABQ
AX
AMEX
AZ
ARM
AQ
ATFN
AMBASSADOR
ACBAQ
AFSI
AFSN
AC
ASEX
AER
AVERY
AGRICULTURE
ASCH
AFU
AMG
ATPDEA
ASECKFRDCVISKIRFPHUMSMIGEG
AORL
BR
BO
BA
BM
BL
BH
BK
BEXP
BILAT
BTIO
BF
BU
BD
BY
BE
BG
BB
BBSR
BT
BRUSSELS
BP
BX
BC
BIDEN
BMGT
BWC
BN
BTIU
CA
CS
CO
CD
CR
CPAS
CDG
CI
CDC
CBW
CU
CVIS
CE
CONS
CH
CMGT
CASC
CY
CW
CG
CJAN
CIDA
CODEL
CWC
CIA
CBSA
CEUDA
CFED
CLINTON
CAC
CL
CACS
CIC
CHR
CAPC
CM
CT
CTR
COM
CROS
CN
COPUOS
CV
CF
CARSON
CONDOLEEZZA
CICTE
CYPRUS
COUNTER
COUNTRY
CBE
CKGR
CVR
COUNTERTERRORISM
CITEL
CLEARANCE
COE
CARICOM
CB
CSW
CITT
CACM
CDB
CJUS
CTM
CAN
CLMT
CBC
CNARC
CIS
EFIN
ECON
ETRD
EAID
EC
EU
EUN
EINV
EG
ETTC
EIND
ELAB
EAGR
ECIN
EINT
ENRG
EFIS
ELTN
EAIR
EPET
EZ
ET
ENERG
ECPS
EWWT
EI
ETRN
EINVECONSENVCSJA
EEPET
EUNCH
ER
ES
EN
EMIN
ESENV
ENNP
ENGR
ETRDEINVECINPGOVCS
ENVI
ECINECONCS
ELN
EFTA
ELECTIONS
ENVR
EXTERNAL
ENIV
ESA
EPA
ETRO
ETRDECONWTOCS
EUR
ECUN
EXIM
EK
EUREM
ECONOMY
EUMEM
ERNG
EFINECONCS
EAIDS
ECA
ETRC
EINVEFIN
ETC
EAP
EINN
ECONOMIC
EXBS
ENGY
ECONOMICS
EIAR
EINDETRD
ECONEFIN
EURN
EDU
ETRDEINVTINTCS
ECIP
EFIM
EREL
EINVETC
ECONCS
ETRA
EAIG
EUC
ERD
IQ
IR
IS
IN
IA
IC
IZ
ICRC
ID
IDA
IT
IO
IAEA
ICJ
ICAO
IV
IBRD
IMF
IAHRC
IWC
ILO
ISLAMISTS
IGAD
ILC
ITU
ITF
INRA
INRO
ICTY
INRB
ITALY
IBET
IL
INTELSAT
ISRAELI
IMO
IDP
ICTR
ITRA
IRC
IRAQI
IEFIN
IPR
IIP
INMARSAT
ITPGOV
ITALIAN
INTERNAL
IRS
INTERPOL
IEA
INR
ISRAEL
IZPREL
IRAJ
IF
ITPHUM
IACI
INDO
KPAO
KMDR
KCOR
KNNP
KJUS
KCRM
KDEM
KVPR
KTFN
KPRP
KTIP
KSCA
KSUM
KTEX
KIDE
KIRF
KV
KTIA
KN
KG
KFRD
KWMN
KUNR
KISL
KU
KGHG
KPKO
KOMS
KPAL
KIPR
KMCA
KOMC
KRVC
KSEP
KAWC
KOLY
KWBG
KACT
KFLO
KHIV
KZ
KGIC
KBCT
KDRG
KBTR
KCFE
KE
KHLS
KMPI
KAWK
KPWR
KIRC
KRAD
KFRDCVISCMGTCASCKOCIASECPHUMSMIGEG
KFLU
KPLS
KRIM
KSTH
KDDG
KPRV
KICC
KS
KSAF
KBIO
KREC
KCGC
KCIP
KTDB
KWAC
KPAI
KFRDKIRFCVISCMGTKOCIASECPHUMSMIGEG
KFSC
KSTC
KMFO
KID
KNAR
KMIG
KVRP
KNEI
KGIT
KNSD
KHDP
KSAC
KWMM
KR
KCOM
KAID
KENV
KVIR
KHSA
KO
KCRS
KPOA
KTER
KFIN
KSPR
KTBT
KX
KCMR
KMOC
KCRCM
KBTS
KSEO
KOCI
KNUP
KPAONZ
KNUC
KNNPMNUC
KERG
KSCI
KTLA
KCSY
KTRD
KMRS
KNPP
KJUST
KRCM
KCFC
KCHG
KREL
KFTFN
KLIG
KDEMAF
KGCC
KICA
KHUM
KSEC
KPIN
KESS
KDEV
KPIR
KWWMN
KOM
KWNM
KRFD
KRGY
KIFR
KWMNCS
KPAK
MARR
MOPS
MUCN
MCAP
MNUC
MEPP
MTCRE
MASS
MO
MIL
MX
MAS
MEDIA
MAR
MI
MQADHAFI
MPOS
MTCR
MK
MG
MA
MY
MU
ML
MPS
MW
MD
MARAD
MC
MR
MT
MTRE
MASC
MRCRE
MAPP
MZ
MP
MOPPS
MTS
MLS
MILI
MEPN
MEPI
MEETINGS
MERCOSUR
MCC
MIK
MAPS
MV
MILITARY
MDC
MASSMNUC
NI
NZ
NL
NO
NPT
NATO
NS
NU
NP
NPA
NSFO
NDP
NT
NW
NASA
NSG
NE
NORAD
NAFTA
NG
NATIONAL
NSSP
NV
NSF
NK
NA
NEW
NPG
NR
NGO
NIPP
NZUS
NH
NC
NRR
NAR
NATOPREL
NSC
OIIP
OPRC
OTRA
OEXC
OREP
OSCE
OVIP
OPAD
OBSP
OECD
OFFICIALS
OAS
OPDC
ODIP
OPCW
OES
OFDP
OPIC
OCS
OIC
OHUM
OSCI
OVP
ODC
OIE
OTR
OMIG
OSAC
OFDA
ON
OCII
PREL
PINR
PGOV
PARM
PE
PTER
PHUM
PO
PINS
PREF
PK
PM
POL
PBTS
PNAT
PHSA
PAS
PA
PL
PGIV
PHUMPREL
POGOV
PAK
PEL
PROP
PP
PINL
PBT
PTBS
PG
PINF
PRL
PALESTINIAN
PSEPC
POSTS
PAHO
PHUMPGOV
PGOC
PNR
PREFA
PMIL
POLITICS
POLICY
PROV
PBIO
PREO
PAO
PDOV
PGOF
POV
PCI
PRAM
PSI
POLITICAL
PAIGH
PJUS
PARMS
PROG
PTERE
PRGOV
PORG
PS
PKFK
PSOE
PEPR
PPA
PINT
PMAR
PRELP
PNG
PFOR
PUNE
PGOVLO
PHUMBA
POLINT
PGOVE
PHALANAGE
PARTY
PDEM
PECON
PY
PLN
PHUH
PF
PHUS
PU
PARTIES
PCUL
PGGV
PSA
PGOVSMIGKCRMKWMNPHUMCVISKFRDCA
RU
RS
REGION
REACTION
REPORT
RO
RW
RCMP
RSO
RP
RM
ROOD
RFE
RICE
ROBERT
RSP
RF
RELATIONS
RIGHTS
RIGHTSPOLMIL
RUPREL
SENV
SY
SNAR
SCUL
SP
SF
SW
SOCI
SU
SMIG
SO
SA
SR
SZ
SI
SC
SEVN
SN
STEINBERG
SK
SH
SNARCS
SPCE
SARS
SNARN
SG
SL
SYRIA
SIPRS
SAARC
SNARIZ
SWE
SYR
SEN
SCRS
SAN
ST
SIPDIS
SSA
SPCVIS
SOFA
SENVKGHG
SANC
SHI
SHUM
TU
TSPA
TBIO
TS
TRGY
TINT
TPHY
TN
TW
TH
TZ
TSPL
TP
TBID
TI
TF
TD
TT
TNGD
TL
TC
THPY
TIP
TX
TV
TK
TERRORISM
TO
TRSY
TURKEY
TFIN
TAGS
TR
UK
UNSC
UNGA
UNESCO
UNHRC
UP
UN
USTR
US
UNDC
UY
UNICEF
UNDP
UNMIK
UNAUS
UNCHC
UNCSD
USOAS
UNFCYP
UG
UNIDROIT
UNO
UV
UNHCR
UNEP
USEU
UZ
UNCND
USUN
UNCHR
USNC
USPS
USAID
UE
UNVIE
UAE
UNODC
UNCHS
UNFICYP
UNDESCO
UNC
UNPUOS
Browse by classification
Community resources
courage is contagious
Viewing cable 08SANJOSE695, COSTA RICA GRANTS REFUGEE STATUS TO CHERE LYN TOMAYKO; MAY
If you are new to these pages, please read an introduction on the structure of a cable as well as how to discuss them with others. See also the FAQs
Understanding cables
Every cable message consists of three parts:
- The top box shows each cables unique reference number, when and by whom it originally was sent, and what its initial classification was.
- The middle box contains the header information that is associated with the cable. It includes information about the receiver(s) as well as a general subject.
- The bottom box presents the body of the cable. The opening can contain a more specific subject, references to other cables (browse by origin to find them) or additional comment. This is followed by the main contents of the cable: a summary, a collection of specific topics and a comment section.
Discussing cables
If you find meaningful or important information in a cable, please link directly to its unique reference number. Linking to a specific paragraph in the body of a cable is also possible by copying the appropriate link (to be found at theparagraph symbol). Please mark messages for social networking services like Twitter with the hash tags #cablegate and a hash containing the reference ID e.g. #08SANJOSE695.
Reference ID | Created | Released | Classification | Origin |
---|---|---|---|---|
08SANJOSE695 | 2008-08-26 21:10 | 2011-03-18 21:00 | UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY | Embassy San Jose |
Appears in these articles: http://www.nacion.com/2011-03-18/Investigacion/NotasSecundarias/Investigacion2716690.aspx http://www.nacion.com/2011-03-18/Investigacion/NotasSecundarias/Investigacion2716698.aspx |
VZCZCXYZ0000
RR RUEHWEB
DE RUEHSJ #0695/01 2392110
ZNR UUUUU ZZH
R 262110Z AUG 08
FM AMEMBASSY SAN JOSE
TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC 0037
INFO RUEHZA/WHA CENTRAL AMERICAN COLLECTIVE
RUEAWJA/DEPT OF JUSTICE WASHINGTON DC
UNCLAS SAN JOSE 000695
SIPDIS
SENSITIVE
DEPT FOR WHA/CEN PRM, DRL, CA and DS/CR/CIL; DOJ for OIA; Panama for
LEGAT
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: CASC ASEC PREL PGOV PREF PHUM CS
SUBJECT: COSTA RICA GRANTS REFUGEE STATUS TO CHERE LYN TOMAYKO; MAY
SET PRECEDENT FOR FUTURE CLAIMS
REF: A. San Jose 524
¶B. 07 San Jose 1746
¶C. 07 San Jose 1604
¶1. (SBU) SUMMARY: In an unprecedented move that may have long term
repercussions, Minister of Public Security Del Vecchio granted U.S.
fugitive, Chere Lyn Tomayko, refugee status on July 23, thereby
halting her extradition to the U.S. Tomayko, wanted in Texas to
answer to international child abduction charges, claimed (without
substantiation) that she was a victim of domestic violence and that
the U.S. legal system would be unable to protect her from future
violence if she were extradited. Manipulating the Costa Rican media
and playing to Costa Rica's self-image as a protector of human
rights, Tomayko and her team of supporters were able to persuade Del
Vecchio to confer refugee status even before the Supreme Court had
issued its ruling on Tomayko's extradition. In doing so, the
Minister unilaterally contradicted the long standing extradition
treaty between Costa Rica and the U.S., and opened the GOCR to a
possible avalanche of spurious refugee status requests. The
following is our wrap-up on this case, for the record. END
SUMMARY.
----------
THE ARREST
----------
¶2. (SBU) Tomayko has been wanted since 2000 under a federal
indictment for parental child abduction. She fled to Costa Rica in
1997 with her daughter Alexandria after a protracted custody battle
with the father of the child, Amcit Roger Cyprian. Of note, during
the battle, Tomayko did not allege any domestic violence; she first
raised the issue just before she received refugee status in July
2008, and there is no record of prior domestic violence complaints
against Cyprian. A provisional warrant was obtained when she was
located in the summer of 2007, and she was arrested by Costa Rican
authorities in September 2007 (Refs. A-C). Soon after her arrest
and the start of extradition proceedings, Tomayko and her team of
supporters went into high gear to block her return to the U.S.
----------------------------------------
THE MARRIAGE (TO A COSTA RICAN NATIONAL)
----------------------------------------
¶3. (SBU) Tomayko first attempted to avoid extradition by marrying
her live-in Costa Rican partner (and father of two of her children).
The Costa Rican constitution forbids the extradition of Costa Rican
citizens and an expedited naturalization process exists for the
spouses of Costa Ricans. Marriage is thus often used by individuals
in extremis wishing to avoid having to leave the country. Tomayko
and her partner, after a courtship of five plus years and the birth
of two children, were married inside her prison in April 2008.
However, as the extradition treaty between Costa Rica and the U.S.
stipulates that naturalization proceedings for fugitives must be
suspended while requests for extradition are pending, Tomayko's
position was still insecure.
---------------
THE ALLEGATIONS
---------------
¶4. (SBU) Then, Tomayko shared her story widely and publicly,
building a coalition to help her avoid extradition. With the help
of her legal team, she gained the ear of several sympathetic
governmental and non-governmental groups, including the Public
Defender's Office, the National Women's Institute (Spanish acronym
INAMU), and the Ombudsman's Office of the GOCR. Local media helped
by painting the extradition request as a callous move which would
"separate an abused mother from her children." To all the parties
involved, Tomayko repeated her unsubstantiated allegations of
domestic violence suffered at the hands of Cyprian and her fear that
she and her daughter would be in danger if they were returned to the
U.S.
¶5. (U) NOTE: Tomayko's case already had enjoyed some notoriety in
the local media. This was due to expatriate media outlets
(ironically) claiming that the U.S. Embassy had "protected" Tomayko
from Cyprian since 2002 by allegedly dragging its feet in passing
information to the FBI regarding Tomayko's whereabouts. These
allegations are untrue. END NOTE.
----------------------
THE REQUEST FOR REFUGE
----------------------
¶6. (SBU) Having put together her strategy and her team, Tomayko
formally requested refugee status from the Immigration Director.
However, the Director was unwilling to act on unsubstantiated
allegations of abuse or the idea that the U.S. legal system was
unable to protect her. Finding no legal basis under Costa Rican law
or international law for granting her request, the Director refused
her application and a subsequent appeal.
--------------
THE FINAL PUSH
--------------
¶7. (SBU) With her scheduled July 17, 2008, extradition date drawing
near, Tomayko and her team filed three habeas corpus petitions to
the Supreme Court, postponing her extradition until the Court could
rule. Regrettably, a carnival-like atmosphere prevailed as her
family, supporters, and the Costa Rican media set up shop outside
the prison where she was being held. Meanwhile, more and more
pressure was brought to bear on Minister Janina Del Vecchio to
overrule the Director of Immigration (who reports to her) and grant
refugee status.
¶8. (SBU) Tomayko and her supporters continued to use the domestic
violence issue to portray her and her daughter as victims being
punished unfairly by the U.S. judicial system. None of Tomayko's
supporters questioned the lack of evidence of domestic violence at
the hands of ex-partner Cyprian. Del Vecchio herself acknowledged
to reporters that no inquires were made to the federal judge in
Texas who originally handled the child custody case, to the FBI, or
to any other U.S. authority to verify the abuse allegations, and
offers of assistance from the U.S. Embassy to help establish the
facts were ignored.
¶9. (U) On July 21, the Embassy sent a Diplomatic Note (our third on
the Tomayko case since August 2007) reiterating that there were no
allegations of domestic abuse against Cyprian, and that he had no
police or criminal record. The Note also stressed that Tomayko
could present her arguments before the appropriate U.S. court, and
that there were many legal and social organizations in the U.S. that
could provide protection against domestic violence or abuse, if any
were proven. The Note expressed our concern about the implications
from the habeas corpus petitions which could (if accepted) make
Costa Rica a safehaven for law breakers from other countries.
Finally, the Note reminded the GOCR that per our bilateral
extradition treaty, naturalization proceedings should be suspended
until any related extradition request had been adjudicated. (Note
No. 123 emailed to WHA/CEN on August 18.)
-----------------------
THE UNILATERAL DECISION
-----------------------
¶10. (SBU) On July 23, with the expected Supreme Court ruling just
days away, Del Vecchio held a press conference to announce that she
was granting refugee status to Tomayko in order to protect her human
rights. Del Vecchio implied that Costa Rica "had" to take this
action because 1) it was their duty as a world leader in the
protection of human rights; and 2) the U.S. legal system would not,
or could not, protect Tomayko from her ex-partner. Little thought
was given to the rights of the left-behind parent, Roger Cyprian, or
the arguments presented in our Diplomatic Note. In fact, during a
phone conversation earlier that day on the Tomayko case, Del Vecchio
gave the DCM no hint of what she planned to do.
¶11. (SBU) Del Vecchio held firm when the Ambassador and DCM met with
her and Vice Minister Ana Duran on July 24. The Ambassador and DCM
expressed USG disappointment with her ruling, and concern about the
damaging precedent it could set for Costa Rica. Del Vecchio stood
by her decision (and her right as Minister, to act unilaterally,
without consulting more widely in the government). She maintained,
as she had said in her press conference, that the Tomayko ruling was
a "one-time decision".
¶12. (SBU) Late on July 24, the Embassy issued a strongly-worded
statement echoing what the Ambassador and DCM had told the Minister
in private, i.e., expressing disappointment in the Minister's
decision, defending U.S. commitment to human rights, and raising
concern about the implications of the legal precedent being set
(text forwarded to WHA that day). However, the die was cast. Given
the Minister's decision, the Supreme Court ruled on July 25 that
Tomayko could not be extradited as a refugee and she was freed. On
July 26, even President Arias was applauding the decision as a
"sovereign" act to "protect human rights," while supportive
commentators were noting the "historic" nature of the decision.
-------------------------------
COMMENT: A DANGEROUS PRECEDENT?
-------------------------------
¶13. (SBU) Despite the legal arguments, Del Vecchio made a clearly
political decision, which resonated with the Costa Rican body
politic, including the President. In a later conversation with the
Ambassador, Del Vecchio made it clear she had strong personal
reasons to be receptive to Tomayko's concerns. However, as some
Costa Rican legal commentators have already noted (and as MFA staff
have worried to us in private), her ruling may have set a dangerous
precedent, leading to spurious refugee claims in the future. (In
fact, in another child abduction case, Amcit Nicole Kater has filed
a refugee claim here on behalf of her daughter, Tierra Kater-Gehl,
to prevent Tierra's father from returning the girl to the United
States.) Having established that a petitioner can merely state that
they have been the victim of domestic violence without offering
proof could bring the GOCR more than it bargained for.
Additionally, we are concerned that this case represents a
disservice to those who have legitimate claims to protection from
domestic violence.
¶14. (SBU) We will continue to monitor this situation carefully, and
stronger follow-up action may be required if future extraditions are
placed in jeopardy by the "refugee gambit". Sadly, although Tomayko
has avoided returning to the U.S. to answer for her crime, she
remains a fugitive with outstanding international arrest warrants
against her. She has thus effectively made herself a "prisoner for
life" in Costa Rica.
CIANCHETTE